Trust in negotiation is more than a virtue – it’s the very cornerstone upon which your journey to successful and lasting outcomes is built. It serves as a platform for reaching amicable, win-win agreements.

In this article, we’ll explore the layers of trust in negotiations, and outline strategies to help you establish trust from the outset, communication methods that strengthen trustworthy practices, and dissect the critical role of consistency and reliability.

Explore a wealth of negotiation preparation insights and diverse expertise on the Mastering Negotiations podcast.

Elevate your skills and gain a broad understanding of transferable knowledge that can empower your success.

Negotiating can be a tough nut to crack. However, when there’s mutual trust between you and the opposing party, this can prove to be a game-changer in paving the way for success, whilst a lack of trust can make your experience all the more complicated.

Trust serves as a bridge that facilitates clear communication. Mutual trust enables you and the other party to communicate openly and with transparency.

Trust in negotiation fosters collaboration and transforms a scenario involving two conflicting parties into a joint effort comprising shared goals. In an environment of trust, you and the other party are more willing to share information, explore creative solutions, and work towards outcomes that benefit everyone involved.

When trust in negotiation is lacking, you’re running the risk of entering discussions clouded by suspicion and doubt. This will lead to your discussions becoming strained and trepidations of hidden motives and agendas will begin to manifest

In a business deal, if you doubt the sincerity of the other party, it can lead to a breakdown in communication and missed opportunities for collaboration.

On the other hand, if you build an environment of trust from the offset, your communications will be open and seamless, opening avenues for additional deals in the future, as highlighted by Jo Derriman, Senior Client Director at Huthwaite International.

“You need to explore where you can grow opportunities. With most business negotiations, you're looking at building long-term relationships and doing business with a company repeatedly.

“Think about where you can grow the relationship and the outcome. Expanding your thinking allows you to have better tradable items, rather than focusing on a small portion of the pie.”

As the adage goes, ‘You don’t get a second chance to make a first impression’. You need to lay the foundation for trust in negotiation from the outset to set off on the right foot.

Your initial exchanges will set the tone for the entire negotiation, and the other party will make quick judgement calls about you based on your conduct when they first meet you. It's essential to be mindful of your communication style and overall presentation.

During negotiations, be as transparent as possible. Transparency stands out as a cornerstone for building trust, and openly sharing information demonstrates a willingness to be forthright. 

Communicate your objectives and expectations to establish a transparent environment conducive to trust. Avoid harbouring hidden agendas, as transparency builds a foundation of honesty, a vital element for a trustworthy negotiation dynamic.

Finetune your negotiation skills and gain indispensable tips to suit your organisation with the Mastering Negotiations podcast.

Consistency is invaluable in helping you build trust. Upholding your end of the bargain and following through with commitments is crucial, regardless of how big or small those promises may be. 

Delivering on them enhances your reliability, showcases your trustworthiness and improves the likelihood of securing an outcome you’re happy with.

Meeting deadlines, honouring agreements, and delivering on expectations consistently fosters a positive perception and contributes to a trustworthy negotiation dynamic.

When you make promises and commitments, don’t set unrealistic expectations and set yourself up for a fall. If you overcommit, you’ll run the risk of not meeting expectations and this can have a detrimental impact on the trust you’ve worked so hard to gain.

If you find yourself in a position where unforeseen circumstances arise that may affect your ability to meet a commitment, communicate openly. Transparency in such instances helps maintain trust by managing expectations.

Recognising the role of consistency and actively incorporating it into your negotiation approach strengthens your credibility and fosters a sense of trust throughout the entire process.

It’s important to acknowledge that challenges may arise during negotiations that could impede trust. However, where there’s a problem, there’s a solution. The key is to understand how to react so you can address these challenges promptly and protect your relationship with the party you’re in talks with.

Firstly, trust can be tested by communication gaps, where messages are unclear or misinterpreted. Don’t be afraid to seek clarification and ask questions if needed, to ensure that you and the other side are on the same wavelength.

As mentioned previously, a perceived lack of transparency can cause problems during your negotiation. You can overcome this easily by being transparent in your actions and decisions. Share information openly, explain your thought process, and address concerns proactively to build and maintain trust.

Whilst it can be awkward to address potential trust issues, you mustn’t wait for the opposition to make the first move and be proactive. This is key to preventing the escalation of trust issues, and you mustn’t let them linger. 

Initiate open conversations, actively listen to concerns, and work collaboratively to find solutions. Prompt and transparent resolution demonstrates your commitment to trust and strengthens the negotiation dynamic.

Tony Hughes, CEO at Huthwaite International, explains why businesses ought to focus on laying the foundation for long-term relationships, and why reaching a mutually beneficial agreement is important.

“If you have a longer-term relationship, there may be the potential to negotiate more than one deal. It’s more valuable for both sides to do a deal together than it is for one side to go off and do a deal with somebody else. In that sense, the opportunity will grow and won’t just be about a one-off negotiation.

“However, if you're not interested in a long-term relationship and you only want the best for you at that particular time, then you may not need to create a win-win negotiation, which is when both sides are going to go away with something valuable to them.” 

50/50 or not, this doesn’t detract from the importance of trust in a negotiation. By adopting the aforementioned methods, you pave the way for a negotiation environment where trust can thrive.